The Penny Dreadful 500 (Season 38) (Penny Dreadful) Decks

MTGGoldfish is supported by its audience. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission.

The Penny Dreadful 500 (Season 38)

Format: Penny Dreadful
Date: 2025-09-20

Place	Deck	Pilot	Tabletop Price	MTGO Price	Toggle Deck
9 - 1	Colorless Cloudpost Ramp	mdog	$ 147	3 tix	Expand

8 - 1	Squirrel Aristocrats	violetteavi	$ 180	2 tix	Expand

7 - 2	Archfiend Alteration	waroomtguc	$ 49	1 tix	Expand

7 - 3	Lumbertwin	frzpop	$ 131	1 tix	Expand

5 - 2	Boros Humans	chickeninthebrain	$ 105	1 tix	Expand

5 - 2	Orzhov Humans	darvill	$ 58	1 tix	Expand

5 - 2	Seismic Swans	dl23	$ 55	1 tix	Expand

5 - 2	Lumbertwin	josha6337	$ 121	2 tix	Expand

5 - 2	Graveyard Value	miss_input	$ 148	2 tix	Expand

5 - 3	Oops All Lands	coupoutous	$ 99	2 tix	Expand

5 - 3	Lifegain Midrange	jaycearveduin	$ 222	1 tix	Expand

5 - 3	Selesnya Heroic	suvelaspurgy	$ 108	2 tix	Expand

5 - 3	Lumbertwin	swiftwarkite2	$ 118	2 tix	Expand

4 - 3	Dredge	c001357	$ 41	3 tix	Expand

4 - 3	Mono Blue Cloudpost Control	excylis	$ 131	3 tix	Expand

4 - 3	Orzhov Humans	gerry_lo_speziato	$ 64	1 tix	Expand

4 - 3	Squirrel Aristocrats	magnus24112	$ 142	2 tix	Expand

4 - 3	Azorius Control	mtgfan1996	$ 35	2 tix	Expand

4 - 3	Gruul Midrange	poposin_hyde	$ 147	2 tix	Expand

4 - 3	Seismic Swans	tappedkitty2	$ 55	1 tix	Expand

4 - 3	Combo	tomsoniq	$ 42	2 tix	Expand

4 - 3	Possibility Storm	toodlesdc	$ 127	1 tix	Expand

3 - 2	Goblins	tygrak	$ 126	1 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Goblins	jdfamnlj	$ 125	2 tix	Expand

3 - 3	Lumbertwin	rakura	$ 130	2 tix	Expand

3 - 4	Lumbertwin	garcia_edu	$ 136	2 tix	Expand

3 - 4	Lumbertwin	itskylestyle	$ 171	1 tix	Expand

3 - 4	Red Deck Wins	maxu_como_e_q_pode	$ 40	1 tix	Expand

2 - 1	Four Color Jeskai Ascendancy	bapis	$ 70	1 tix	Expand

2 - 2	The Rock	finaldefiance	$ 120	2 tix	Expand

2 - 2	Sultai Tendrils	restokiki	$ 62	3 tix	Expand

2 - 2	Lumbertwin	thewatchwander	$ 162	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Four Color Jeskai Ascendancy	blacklamb	$ 77	1 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Azorius Control	honorbound84	$ 35	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Dredge	miguelmtg	$ 46	2 tix	Expand

2 - 3	Red Deck Wins	xigotdeadx	$ 78	2 tix	Expand

2 - 4	Colorless Cloudpost Ramp	_onecurlyboy	$ 146	2 tix	Expand

2 - 5	Wizards	genesissloth	$ 91	1 tix	Expand

2 - 5	Mono Blue Cloudpost Control	pyrohorse	$ 142	3 tix	Expand

2 - 5	Red Deck Wins	xxdragonbornxx	$ 40	1 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Sultai Tendrils	glendaloc	$ 29	3 tix	Expand

1 - 0	Four Color Jeskai Ascendancy	youraverageidiot	$ 77	1 tix	Expand

1 - 2	Possibility Storm	datrobino	$ 125	1 tix	Expand

1 - 2	Red Deck Wins	depressedduck	$ 56	2 tix	Expand

1 - 2	The Rock	eduardo-bianchi	$ 131	2 tix	Expand

1 - 2	Lumbertwin	wizzerinus	$ 144	2 tix	Expand

1 - 3	Izzet Twin	snakeadee001	$ 68	1 tix	Expand

-	Four Color Jeskai Ascendancy	cdnewlon	$ 70	1 tix	Expand

-	Colorless Cloudpost Ramp	roboton	$ 142	2 tix	Expand

-	Izzet Control	jippiedoe	$ 26	2 tix	Expand

Displaying 1 - 50 of 50 in total.

New Cards Being Played

Card	Decks
Karplusan Forest (13)	Lumbertwin (7 - 3) , Lumbertwin (5 - 3) , Lumbertwin (5 - 2) , Possibility Storm (4 - 3) , Gruul Midrange (4 - 3) , ...
Monoist Sentry (12)	Lumbertwin (7 - 3) , Squirrel Aristocrats (8 - 1) , Lumbertwin (5 - 3) , Graveyard Value (5 - 2) , Lumbertwin (5 - 2) , ...
Llanowar Wastes (7)	Squirrel Aristocrats (8 - 1) , Graveyard Value (5 - 2) , Dredge (4 - 3) , Squirrel Aristocrats (4 - 3) , The Rock (2 - 2) , ...
Satyr Wayfinder (5)	Squirrel Aristocrats (8 - 1) , Graveyard Value (5 - 2) , Dredge (4 - 3) , Squirrel Aristocrats (4 - 3) , Dredge (2 - 3)
Sulfur Falls (5)	Seismic Swans (5 - 2) , Seismic Swans (4 - 3) , Combo (4 - 3) , Izzet Twin (1 - 3) , Izzet Control (-)
Cascade Bluffs (5)	Seismic Swans (5 - 2) , Seismic Swans (4 - 3) , Combo (4 - 3) , Izzet Twin (1 - 3) , Izzet Control (-)
Shivan Reef (5)	Seismic Swans (5 - 2) , Seismic Swans (4 - 3) , Combo (4 - 3) , Izzet Twin (1 - 3) , Izzet Control (-)
Twilight Mire (4)	Squirrel Aristocrats (8 - 1) , Graveyard Value (5 - 2) , Squirrel Aristocrats (4 - 3) , The Rock (2 - 2)
Hangarback Walker (3)	Colorless Cloudpost Ramp (9 - 1) , Colorless Cloudpost Ramp (2 - 4) , Colorless Cloudpost Ramp (-)
Annul (3)	Archfiend Alteration (7 - 2) , Azorius Control (4 - 3) , Azorius Control (2 - 3)
Temple of Epiphany (3)	Oops All Lands (5 - 3) , Izzet Twin (1 - 3) , Izzet Control (-)
Chrome Host Seedshark (2)	Izzet Twin (1 - 3) , Izzet Control (-)
Evolving Wilds (2)	Sultai Tendrils (2 - 2) , Sultai Tendrils (1 - 0)
Lonely Sandbar (2)	Wizards (2 - 5) , Izzet Twin (1 - 3)
Plasma Bolt (2)	Red Deck Wins (3 - 4) , Red Deck Wins (2 - 5)
Glacial Fortress (2)	Azorius Control (4 - 3) , Azorius Control (2 - 3)
Canyon Slough (2)	Seismic Swans (5 - 2) , Seismic Swans (4 - 3)
Susurian Voidborn (2)	Squirrel Aristocrats (8 - 1) , Squirrel Aristocrats (4 - 3)
Clifftop Retreat (1)	Boros Humans (5 - 2)
Battlefield Forge (1)	Boros Humans (5 - 2)
Meltstrider's Resolve (1)	Selesnya Heroic (5 - 3)
Titania, Protector of Argoth (1)	Lumbertwin (1 - 2)
Sheltered Thicket (1)	Lumbertwin (7 - 3)

Metagame Summary

Deck	Percentage	Total
Other	40.00%	20
Four Color Jeskai Ascendancy	8.00%	4
Colorless Cloudpost Ramp	6.00%	3
Izzet Twin	4.00%	2
Sultai Tendrils	4.00%	2
Gruul Aggro	4.00%	2
Goblins	4.00%	2
Possibility Storm	4.00%	2
Mono Blue Cloudpost Control	4.00%	2
Dredge	4.00%	2
Orzhov Humans	4.00%	2
Seismic Swans	4.00%	2
Gruul Midrange	2.00%	1
Combo	2.00%	1
Wizards	2.00%	1
The Rock	2.00%	1
Lifegain Midrange	2.00%	1
Total	100.00%	50

Most-Played Cards

Top Cards
	Card	Copies	Decks
1	Fanatic of Rhonas	64	32%
2	Birds of Paradise	55	30%
3	Pithing Needle	49	40%
4	Nature's Rhythm	48	24%
5	Orcish Lumberjack	40	20%
6	Thunder Magic	38	28%
7	Price of Progress	37	20%
8	Memory Lapse	36	20%
9	Void Mirror	35	32%
10	Bristlebud Farmer	34	20%

Top Creatures
	Card	Copies	Decks
1	Fanatic of Rhonas	64	32%
2	Birds of Paradise	55	30%
3	Orcish Lumberjack	40	20%
4	Bristlebud Farmer	34	20%
5	Scrapshooter	32	18%
6	Trumpeting Carnosaur	29	20%
7	Combat Celebrant	24	16%
8	Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker	22	18%
9	Mogg Fanatic	20	12%
10	Satyr Wayfinder	20	10%

Top Spells
	Card	Copies	Decks
1	Pithing Needle	49	40%
2	Nature's Rhythm	48	24%
3	Thunder Magic	38	28%
4	Price of Progress	37	20%
5	Memory Lapse	36	20%
6	Void Mirror	35	32%
7	Repeal	31	20%
8	Alpine Moon	23	24%
9	Burst Lightning	21	12%
10	Mana Leak	21	12%